COMPARISON OF HOUSING TYPES

TYPES OF HOUSING

ADVANTAGES

DISADVANTAGES

Older House

Gassed out

Possible use of Insecticides or termiticides

 

Hardwood floors

Lingering odor of artificial fragrances in closets

 

Solid wood cabinetry

Possible use of asbestos or lead paint

 

“In the Rough” (without remodeling)

Possible remodeling with toxic materials

 

      _remodel with nontoxic materials

Mold from: leaky roof or damp basement

 

Replace old furnace with new furnace system

      _leaky furnace (may transport mold spores)

 

      _new — more efficient and healthful

Old furnace system

     

Lustron House

Suitable for MCS

Not energy efficient

 

Built of steel

Not energy efficient

 

Located in cities with outdoor air pollution

Difficult to hang pictures on walls of steel

   

      _Magnets can be used

     

Mobile Home

Older is healthier

Avoid newer

 

      _25—30 years old

Problems with older

 

paneling & plywood has gassed out

      _closets — fragrances from clothing

 

      _asphalt floors have gassed out

      _remodel with new materials

   

      _poorly insulated

     

Apartments

Older preferred

Newer mass-produced units

 

      _hardwood floors & plaster walls possible

      _least expensive material that contain chemical toxins

 

      _steam heat

Old or new: odors, smells, fumes from other units

 

      _upper floors: greater distance from basement & traffic fumes

 
     

Temporary Housing

Hotels and motels

Tents and campers

 

      _similar to information under apartments

      _tents treated with waterproofing chemicals

   

      _new campers constructed w/man-made products that may contain chemical toxins

     

Remodeling or Building New

Hiring contractor familiar with nontoxic construct

More expensive

 

Allow for gas out time

 
 

Require nontoxic materials and techniques

 

A comparison of housing types matrix that explains the advantages and disadvantages of each type. The matrix uses information from
Bower (1993). Matrix developed by: Linda L. Nussbaumer, Ph.D., ASID, CID; South Dakota State University.